Do the Cops Need to Read You Your Rights?

In the case Arizona v Miranda, the Supreme Court held that a person in custody had to be informed of the right to an attorney, the right to remain silent, and told that anything said, could and would be used against you in Court. The reason for this ruling went to the fact that any statement or confession made to the police had to be made voluntarily, knowingly and willingly before it could be admitted in court. So once the police give you your Miranda Rights, any confession or statement is considered just that, voluntary, knowingly and willingly.

When Miranda Warnings Must Be Given

There is a deep misunderstanding of the Miranda warning that is perpetuated by what we see on television. The greatest misunderstanding is under what circumstances the police have to give you these warnings. The Court held that in the Miranda case that a person had to be in custody. In later cases ruled that “custody” is whether a reasonable person would believe that he or she was restrained or free to go. Reasonableness is not determined by what defendant's thinks nor is the subjective intent of the police relevant to a court's determination whether an individual is in custody unless the officer makes that intent known. So, an individual who voluntarily goes to a police station is not in custody solely by virtue of an officer's subjective view that the individual is not free to leave. There must be an act indicating the intention to take the person into custody. Another example would be if you were walking on the street and a policeman starts to ask you questions, even though you might feel you could not walk away from the officer, you are not considered in custody, the officer can ask all the questions he wants and Miranda warnings are not required.

Miranda Facts


It's Not Like in the Movies or on Television


You must be under duress which means YOU CAN'T LEAVE


The police MAY ask questions if you are NOT under arrest or in custody


You CAN RESPECTFULLY refuse to answer


Miranda Warnings are ONLY required when you are questioned and you are NOT free to leave.

Best Advice is to Keep Your Mouth Shut

If you are questioned by the police, you are not required to say anything. The best advise is that if you are questioned by the police, politely refuse to answer their questions and request an attorney. Once you request an attorney, the officer must stop questioning you and usually will. If they don't, still don't answer and keep politely requesting to speak to a lawyer.

For the Best Criminal Defense Possible
Contact Schmierlaw for an Initial No-Cost Consultation

Contact Us for an Initial No-cost Consultation


Law Office of James G. Schmier, PLLC
2222 Attard Street, Birmingham, Michigan 48009
Tel: (248) 705-3742     FAX: (248) 540-0044    Email: